"That Would Never Happen!" Dan and Ali write the real reviews of UK TV drama serials (stuff marketed as quality, if you please), telling it like it is rather than the my-mate's-the-director, I-get-party-invites, or the I-need-my-job reviews that often appear. Not to mention the I've-not-watched-it....
Showing posts with label Phoebe Nicholls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phoebe Nicholls. Show all posts
Tuesday, 8 March 2016
Doctor Thorne
Who better to adapt one of Trollope's gossipy, class-fixated 19th Century tomes than Downton's Julian Fellowes? This in fact occupies the same 9pm, Sunday-night ITV slot lately vacated by the Crawleys, so don't expect a risk-taking, rule-breaking adaptation. Instead we get a decent cast and a handsomely-mounted hour introducing us to the eponymous Dr Thorne (Tom Hollander - confusingly the camp, bitchy Corkoran over on BBC1 at the same time) and his illegitimate niece Mary, who is in love with the handsome young squire at the big house. He returns that love, but alas has no money and must marry it. Could there be a chance that Mary's unacknowledged other uncle will bestow a fortune on her...? Fans of Trollope's novels will be either delighted or disappointed in the adaptation, but for the rest of us all that can be said is that it competently covers familiar ground.
Labels:
Anthony Trollope,
Ian McShane,
ITV,
Janine Duvitski,
Julian Fellowes,
Phoebe Nicholls,
Rebecca Front,
Richard McCabe,
Tom Hollander
Saturday, 15 September 2012
The Scapegoat
Last night I dreamed I watched 'The Scapegoat' again... and woke up hoping that, should my double exist, I never meet her. A little later than planned, we watched this one-off drama, based on a lesser-known work by Daphne du Maurier. To get around the 1952 story showing its age, this is a sort of Jubilee tribute, set in the Coronation year and drawing parallels between the Queen who was never meant to be, and the usurper John Standing who makes a better fist of his double's life than the real Johnny Spence (both Matthew Rhys).
The Prince and Pauper storyline is a familiar one from fiction (Man in the Iron Mask) and partially in fact (the Titchborne Claimant) and is yet another programme badly trailed. Instead of a lurid thriller, this was an old-fashioned story and while the premise is implausible, Sturridge and his cast have fashioned a decent drama from du Maurier's book.
The ending hints at its being an oblique metaphor for the abdication crisis having a happy outcome. Even the pet goldfish is called Mrs Simpson, and dies, to be buried in a matchbox in the garden. Which is probably a kinder slant than interpreting the moral more directly implied by a close-up of John/Johnny's eyes in the final frame: if you're doing a better job than the real thing, but the real thing wants their role back, it's allowable to dispose of them. Hmmm.
Labels:
Anton Lesser,
Charles Sturridge,
Daphne du Maurier,
Dominic Minghella,
Drama,
Eileen Atkins,
ITV,
Jodhi May,
Julian Wadham,
Matthew Rhys,
Phoebe Nicholls,
Pip Torrens,
Sheridan Smith,
TV,
UK
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

